Five Guys Grilled Cheese features melted American cheese layered between two golden, buttery toasted buns, delivering a warm, gooey, and crispy comfort food classic.
Equipments
- Grill or Flat Top Griddle
- Spatula
- Butter Spreader or Knife
- Bread Knife (optional)
- Cheese Slicer (optional)
- Sandwich Press (optional)
- Serving Tray or Plate
Ingredients
- 4 slices white bread
- 4 slices American cheese
- 2 tablespoons unsalted butter
- 4 slices white bread
- 4 slices American cheese
- 2 tablespoons unsalted butter
Be sure to use unsalted butter to control the saltiness and achieve the perfect golden, crispy texture on your white bread. Fresh American cheese slices are essential for that signature gooey melt that defines Five Guys Grilled Cheese. Avoid doubling bread slices unnecessarily to maintain the classic sandwich size and consistency. Using a grill or flat top griddle helps evenly toast the bread while melting the cheese perfectly. Your homemade Five Guys Grilled Cheese will closely mimic the warm, buttery, and cheesy comfort food classic found on their copycat menu.
Instructions
- Instructions:
- Preheat grill or flat top griddle to medium heat.
- Spread butter evenly on one side of each bread slice using butter spreader or knife.
- Place half of the bread slices, buttered side down, onto the hot griddle.
- Layer 2 slices of American cheese on each bread slice on the griddle.
- Top with the remaining bread slices, buttered side up.
- Grill until the bottom bread is golden brown, about 2-3 minutes.
- Carefully flip sandwiches with a spatula.
- Grill the other side until golden brown and cheese is fully melted, about 2-3 minutes more.
- Remove sandwiches from the griddle.
- Slice in half if desired.
- Serve immediately on a tray or plate.
Substitution
Five Guys Grilled Cheese, a copycat version of the popular menu item, combines melted American cheese with buttery toasted white bread for a perfectly crispy and gooey experience. If you don't have American cheese, cheddar or mozzarella can be used as a substitute, though the flavor and melt texture may vary slightly. Instead of a sandwich press, using a heavy skillet or grill pan while pressing down with a spatula helps achieve a similar toasted crust. When spreading butter, softened or melted butter spreads more evenly, ensuring a golden finish on each bread slice. Your grilled cheese will turn out best when you cook it over medium heat to avoid burning while allowing the cheese to fully melt.
Tips
To achieve the perfect Five Guys Grilled Cheese, make sure the griddle is heated to medium before placing the sandwiches to ensure even melting and crispiness. Butter should be spread evenly on the bread to prevent burning and to create a golden, buttery crust. Use a spatula to flip the sandwiches gently to avoid spilling melted cheese. Your sandwiches are best served immediately to enjoy the blend of gooey cheese and crispy bread at its freshest.
Nutritions
The Five Guys Grilled Cheese provides a rich source of calcium from the melted American cheese, supporting bone health. The sandwich contains approximately 400-500 calories per serving, mainly from fats and carbohydrates due to the butter and white bread. Sodium content may be high, so moderating your intake is advisable if you monitor salt consumption. You can enjoy this comfort food while being mindful of portion size to balance indulgence with nutritional needs.
Storage
Store any leftover Five Guys Grilled Cheese sandwiches in an airtight container in the refrigerator to maintain freshness and prevent sogginess. Reheat them on a grill or flat top griddle over medium heat to restore the crispy, buttery texture and gooey melted cheese. For best results, avoid microwaving as it can make the bread chewy and the cheese unevenly melted.
Variation or Alternatives
Try substituting white bread with sourdough or multigrain for added texture and flavor. Using a blend of American and sharp cheddar cheese can enhance the gooeyness and taste complexity. Instead of spreading butter directly, brush the bread with garlic-infused olive oil for a savory twist. You might also press the sandwich in a sandwich press or panini maker for even grilling and a crispier crust.
Allergies
Five Guys Grilled Cheese contains common allergens such as dairy from the American cheese and butter, as well as gluten from the white bread. If you have a milk allergy or lactose intolerance, consuming this sandwich could cause adverse reactions. You should also be cautious if you have a gluten sensitivity or celiac disease due to the wheat-based bread.
Why this recipe?
Five Guys' Grilled Cheese stands out for its perfectly melted, gooey cheese layered between freshly toasted, buttered buns, delivering a comforting and flavorful bite every time. The quality of their ingredients, including premium American cheese and soft, fresh bread, creates a rich and satisfying taste profile that keeps customers coming back. Making a copycat recipe allows you to recreate this indulgent experience at home, customizing flavors and avoiding restaurant wait times. Your homemade version can capture that signature melt and crunch, making it a delicious and cost-effective alternative.